Confidence When You Need It
As usual, you never see it coming. Suddenly my dog became lethargic, stopped playing, stood in front of his food bowl for a minute before half-heartedly eating. I sometimes ponder the importance of the monthly premium for pet insurance, at least when things are going well. But suddenly they aren't, and I'm happy to not have to worry about making choices due to finances at least. Turns out Lincoln had spiked a fever, and after bloodwork and an x-ray, it was still a mystery. My vet's best guess was to treat with antibiotics, which she said in a small amount of mystery cases such as this, helped resolve the problem. A good guess, and Lincoln recovered well within just a few days. Within a couple weeks after filing my claim, Pets Best reimbursed me, and sent me my EOB, all which were completely easy to understand. In my experience, this has been consistent behavior for this company over Lincoln's entire lifetime since puppyhood. He is now 8, and it's a no brainer for me anymore.
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
Explore other options before over paying for subpar insurance
I wish I never switched to Pets "Best"
- INSURER:
Pets Best
- POSTED: 06/11/2025
- BY: Jon
- BREED: Tuxedo
- AGE OF PET: 0 - 3
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
Pets Best is perfectly named
I have had Pets Best for my two dogs for about five years now and this might be the single best insurance company I've ever worked with. They've processed and paid claims with complete ease and great communication.. My 12 year old dog was recently diagnosed with cancer and they have covered all aspects of his care without any kind of resistance. I wish human health insurance was this good! Their service is, without a doubt, worth every penny I pay for premiums.
- INSURER:
Pets Best
- POSTED: 06/11/2025
- BY: Amy
- BREED: Australian Cattle Dog
- AGE OF PET: Over 11 years
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
Pleasantly surprised
Next, share your review on PetInsuranceReview.com! To make it easier, here's what you shared with us on your claims story:
"This is the first time I've used Pet's Best" pet insurance for my dog. I was surprised that they were satisfied with the documentation that I turned in, I have had pet coverage for twenty plus years and I was amazed at how seamless the process was. No calling or emailing me for additional information.It MAY be a tad bit more expensive but I think it's worth it for the peace of mind knowing that I don't have to jump through hoops to get reimbursed. If things continue to go the way the past claim went I will be 100% satisfied."
- INSURER:
Pets Plus Us
- VETERINARIAN:
Sylvan Vetererinary Hospital
- POSTED: 06/11/2025
- BY: Vicki
- BREED: Great Pyrenees
- AGE OF PET: 0 - 3
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
Happy Pet Owner
Pets Best has been very good to work with and the claims processing is quick and easy. The rates are reasonable and coverage great. I would definitely recommend to any pet owner interested in pet insurance.
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
Need improvement
We used to have Healthy Paws but with 2 new dogs we tried Pets Best. Their price on one dog was lower but slightly higher on the other. We submitted a claim and it came back and they paid it as it should be paid however they took much longer to pay than healthy paws. I also don't like that they can't mail you a check this way I can tell that they paid it. Instead I had to keep checking my account to see if the money went in. I will reevaluate my contract when it's up.
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
Love this Company
Can't say enough about this Company. Our dog Rose had an unexpected accident which tore both her acls. Pets Best was there for us all the way. Easy to file claims and prompt processing. THANK YOU pets Best!!!!
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
PetsPlusUs never let us down
Our dog was diagnosed with CKD in 2024. These last 1.5y has been very challenging, but PetsPlusUs has been there for us. We definitely recommend.
- INSURER:
Pets Plus Us
- POSTED: 06/10/2025
- BY: Ana Carolina
- BREED: Shih Tzu
- AGE OF PET: Over 11 years
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
I love Pet's Best
Pets Best is a great pet insurance. Submitting claims are really easy via the website or the app, which I have on my phone. I just snap a picture of the receipt, click the relevant options, and I can do the whole thing in a couple of minutes. Claim processing is usually timely, and the explanations are clear to understand. When my dog, Smudge, was bit by another dog, I was able to submit a claim for the bill and, because we'd met our deductible, we only owed less than $100 of a $4,000 bill. Pets Best lets me know we can get the care we need for our dog with peace of mind about the costs.
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
Avoid the Frustration!
I deeply regret switching to Pets Best from Nationwide,this has been the worst pet insurance experience I've ever had. The biggest issue is their claim denials; a significant majority of the claims I submit are rejected without clear justification, making it feel like their priority is avoiding payouts rather than supporting pet owners.
On the rare occasion they do approve a claim, the reimbursement process is painfully slow, often taking weeks before I see any funds. This delay is frustrating, especially when dealing with urgent veterinary expenses. Having been with multiple pet insurance providers, I can confidently say Pets Best has been the most disappointing in terms of reliability and efficiency.
If you're looking for peace of mind and timely coverage for your pet, I strongly recommend exploring other options. My experience has been nothing short of frustrating, and I truly regret making the switch.
Did you find this review helpful?
Yes
No
